Manchester United have been made aware of a possible route back to Old Trafford for Scott McTominay, with his future at Napoli far from settled heading into 2027. According to TeamTalk, the Scotland international is facing growing uncertainty in Italy as talks over a new deal have yet to find common ground.
The 29-year-old has only 18 months left on his current Napoli contract, and the latest indications suggest there is still a sizeable gap between club and player. Napoli want to keep him, that much is clear, but the report states that negotiations “are not progressing towards an agreement”, creating a situation that is now being watched closely in England and beyond.
Scott McTominay Back on Manchester United Radar
McTominay’s departure from Manchester United in 2024 felt like the right move for all parties at the time. He had come through the academy, established himself in the first team and offered reliability in a variety of midfield roles, but a fresh start was needed. Since then, his career has accelerated in Serie A.
His time in Naples is described as “transformative”, and that word carries weight. The report adds that he has “taken his game to another level”, developing into “a genuine top-class midfielder” and becoming “one of Napoli’s most influential players”. Those are not throwaway lines. They point to a player who has matured, broadened his game and raised his standing considerably since leaving Manchester.
That progress has not gone unnoticed at Old Trafford. Manchester United “have been informed of his potential availability”, and the prospect of bringing him back “has not been dismissed out of hand”. In a summer and medium-term planning cycle where midfield remains central to recruitment thinking, that matters.
Napoli Contract Talks Open Door for Premier League Move
Napoli remain keen to tie McTominay down, but the impasse in negotiations has encouraged movement behind the scenes. The report says “intermediaries are now working on potential options for McTominay heading into 2027, with a return to English football firmly among the possibilities being explored”.
For United, the timing is notable. Mauricio Pochettino is overseeing a rebuild and midfield is expected to be one of the key areas under review. With “uncertainty surrounding the future of captain Bruno Fernandes”, there is every chance of a significant reshaping in the centre of the pitch.
McTominay would offer clear advantages. He knows the club, understands the demands of the Premier League and has added fresh authority to his game in Italy. The report specifically points to his “familiarity with the club, Premier League experience and considerable development since leaving Old Trafford” as reasons why he could appeal.
Transfer Competition Builds Around Napoli Midfielder
United are not operating in isolation. Chelsea are also watching closely, with the report stating they “recognise his qualities” and value his ability to influence games at both ends of the pitch. That is an important detail because it suggests this is not nostalgia-driven interest. It is market-wide recognition of a midfielder whose profile now carries broader appeal.
There is also heavyweight interest in Italy. TEAMtalk reports that both AC Milan and Juventus “are huge admirers” of McTominay and are tracking developments around his contract position. Saudi Pro League clubs are in the picture too, armed with the financial capacity to become serious contenders if Napoli fail to secure an extension.
As things stand, McTominay is said to be “open-minded about his future” and willing to consider staying in Italy while discussions continue. At the same time, the report adds that “a return to the Premier League is an option he would be more than open to considering”. That leaves the situation delicately poised.
For Manchester United, this is one to monitor rather than one approaching a conclusion. There is no indication of advanced talks, no suggestion of a formal push, and no sign yet that Napoli are ready to concede defeat. But awareness has been established, the market is moving and a player who once left Old Trafford may now be back within range.
Our View
Bringing McTominay back would make a lot of sense if the finances are right. He knows the club, he understands the pressure and, crucially, he looks like a better player now than when he left. Sometimes players need to step away to become what they were always capable of being, and everything in this report points to exactly that happening in Naples.
There would be obvious questions about whether a return is too sentimental, but this does not read like sentiment. It reads like a club being alerted to a proven midfielder who has added consistency, leadership and end product to his game. If Bruno Fernandes leaves, or even if the midfield is simply rebalanced, those qualities would be valuable.
What stands out most is the line that he has become “one of Napoli’s most influential players”. Manchester United need more of that profile, players who affect matches, carry authority and can cope with big expectations. McTominay always had heart and commitment. If he now adds top-class form and greater composure, then this should be taken seriously.
The key is price and role. He should not come back as a symbolic signing. He should come back to compete hard, raise standards and improve the midfield. If that opportunity is genuinely there, United would be wise to explore it properly.

